A Simple Chance For The Family To Be Faithful And Traitors, But At The Cost Of Depth
Forest of Deceit arrived at the right time for my family. Fresh off the back of Celebrity Traitors, and with a daughter who’s just found party games like Werewolves and Mafia, we were ready to backstab each other. Forest of Deceit taps into that social deduction vein, forcing you and your friends/family to barefaced lie to each other. It doesn’t take much prompting for my family to do a spot of scheming.
You don’t need much to play Forest of Deceit. Each player needs a screen to receive their personalised information, and that can be a tablet, phone or laptop. In a very Jackbox style, everyone navigates to the Forest of Deceit web page, types in the bespoke room code, and – as long as you have a minimum of 4 players and a maximum of 8 players – a game can start.

A Traitor In Our Midst
The flow of a game is always the same. Roles are allocated first. One or more of you take on the role of Traitor, while the others are the faithful – sorry, the Innocent. These are obviously kept private. Then it’s time for the game proper, where the Innocents have a simple goal: they need to gather enough resources to build a shelter so that they can survive an incoming storm that drops in six days. It’s not made clear why the Traitors would want to get in the way of that – presumably they want a dry place to sleep as much as anyone else – but sabotage them they do.
Each day, a temporary leader gets to determine the foraging parties. Everyone is partnered up, unless the group is an odd number, at which point one person goes it alone. In those partnerships, one of them is given three resource cards. These can be bad resources (worth 0 or even negative values) or good resources, and there are more bad resources than good. That player removes one of the resources, and hands the remaining two to their partner. They remove another, and the resulting resource is added (or removed if negative) from the community pool.
Everyone reconvenes, finds out what the team foraged (cue lots of “you gave me rubbish!”, “but I only had bad resources to choose from!”), and discusses who might be the Traitor. Often, there’s not much the team can do right now, as there are very specific moments for evicting the Traitor from the team (unlike Werewolves or Traitors, where evictions/lynching happens daily). But it informs the foraging partnerships, as players try to keep Traitors by themselves, or whatever tactics they want to employ.
There’s Joy To Be Had From Accusing Your Own Kids As Traitors
Eventually, there is the opportunity to evict, and this is the time to get rid. Traitors will try to make a case for evicting the Innocent, all the while keeping the scrutiny off them. If the Traitors are all removed, the Innocents automatically win. If the Innocents also manage to build the shelter in time, they win. But if they don’t, the Traitors take the trophy.
There are a few quirks here and there. Since there is a storm approaching, weather plays a part. Some days are rainy or overcast, and these are the days where players are more likely to become ‘Lost’. Most of the time, this is random: a Lost player will be randomly determined, and they will have to sit out 1-2 days of playtime. But the Traitors can also tap a button that ‘loses’ their partner in a foraging trip, or even get Lost themselves. It’s an extra power for the Traitors that can draw attention if not used wisely (using the power on a sunny day, for example, is asking for trouble).

And that’s it. Forest of Deceit is definitely focused on embracing every possible player. Its Xbox Store page says ‘someone who’s never played a game in their life’ could play Forest of Deceit and they would be right. There are only two cards in the entire game, and only two roles. Everything that needs to be done is clearly displayed on the screen. There are nuances that only better players will pick up on – knowing when to use the ‘Lost’ mechanic, for example – but generally anyone can play or win. My eight-year old managed to be a Traitor four times in a row, and not once did we accuse her. You’d think we would have learned.
Easy To Learn, A Little Boring To Master
That simplicity is – as it often is – both a benefit and problem. The benefit is that we could all sit down and play within five minutes. The tutorial is clear, and we all firmly understood what was wanted from us. The ability to play on any screen made the game massively accessible, and the games were far from long. We finished each one in roughly ten minutes, and there’s encouragement to have just one more go.
Being so simple, it was easy for all players to wrangle with suspicious play. If a two-player team comes back with nothing, then an interrogation needs to happen. Who gave who the bad resources? Were there any good resources to start with? Getting Lost is a little more complicated, but that also raises suspicion. Once the team is aware that getting Lost can be a product of a Traitor, the accusations start flying. Lost players can’t talk in these exchanges, so it’s fun to watch the chaos from the fringes.
Coming from a fan of social deduction games, though, Forest of Deceit does get damaged by that simplicity. You don’t have a huge number of information points to determine an Innocent or Traitor, for one. If you’re the second player in a partnership, you would be extremely foolish to sabotage play, since the player who went before you knows the cards you were given. If you’re given one good and one bad resource, and keep the bad, then the first player is going to be out of their seat faster than you can say ‘Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney‘. You’re forced to keep things tight, which isn’t all that fun.
Accuse The Chatty Ones
With less of an emphasis on sabotaging play, the game is often only as good as the team that you’re playing with. You need storytellers and outgoing players who are willing to talk and accuse. Forest of Deceit feels like it demands a lot of offline play to really catalyse the matches. I would also suggest that playing with only 4 players is a bit rubbish: the impact of being ‘lost’ is so much greater on a smaller team, and Traitors can’t blend into the background.
I’m also massively dubious of the Lost mechanic. Removing a player for 1 or 2 turns just isn’t enjoyable. Sitting there, unable to play or talk, for up to one third of the game’s length, is anti-fun. And there’s no cooldown on getting Lost. You can be removed from the game the very next turn, if the Traitor is feeling sufficiently mean.

I can’t help feeling, after several games of Forest of Deceit, that the simplicity ends up hurting it more than serving it. We all agreed to take it off the Multiplayer playlist and probably never play it again. The fans of social deduction games desperately wished that there was more variance and depth in Forest of Deceit, perhaps through more roles or cards. The less experienced players got tired of being Lost all the time, and generally had low-level fatigue. Neither group felt satisfied.
For the couple of hours that we were gathered around its campfire, Forest of Deceit was the Forest of Decent. We accused each other of being Traitors, withered under each other’s glare, and generally chuckled at each other’s misfortune. But while I appreciated that everyone could play without confusing tutorials or a multiplicity of roles, I could also sense that this was going to be a fleeting experience. Forest of Deceit was too surface-level and prone to infuriation, mainly thanks to its Lost mechanic, to be anything other than a dalliance. After Celebrity Traitors, we were hungry for a little more than that.
Important Links
Buy from the Xbox Store – https://www.xbox.com/en-GB/games/store/forest-of-deceit/9p014w4nbs30

