HomeReviews4.5/5 ReviewForgive Me Father 2 Review

Forgive Me Father 2 Review

-

Best of 2025

A Boomer Shooter Sequel That Delivers

There is something about a good, old-fashioned, fast first-person shooter that never gets old. It’s a tried-and-true formula where you run through labyrinthine areas, blasting away at hordes of enemies while constantly acquiring new, more powerful weapons and facing ever-larger foes. 

DOOM is the undisputed master of this genre, the benchmark from which all other good “boomer shooters” hope to draw inspiration and, ideally, innovate upon. The original Forgive Me Father came along two years ago, and while we reviewed it well, we felt that its relentless action got a bit too one-note in places, lacking some variety. Many fans wouldn’t agree with that sentiment, and after playing the second game in the franchise, perhaps we were a little harsh in our initial judgment. 

Forgive Me Father, as a sequel, is an absolute blast, full of kinetic energy. Here’s why, in this case, the follow-up is king.

Forgive Me Father 2 review 1
Shooting through madness

A Descent into Madness

While this is, at its core, a game about shooting things with very big guns, there is also a surprisingly deep narrative at play. It follows on directly from the first game, and after those events, it places you, the protagonist, in a mental asylum. You reprise the role of the priest, a man haunted by his past. The world is steeped in a Lovecraftian theme, and as is often the case with such stories, the central focus is on a terrifying descent into madness. Your asylum acts as a sort of game hub, a place where you can rest from the horrors and level up your abilities. 

From there, you venture out into different environments that manifest as twisted memories, such as a university, a cathedral, or the trenches of a war zone. The priest’s gravelly voice-over confirms that these are his own warped reflections. You’ll also find items that further enhance the story, such as discarded leaflets or forgotten books. It’s a well-crafted narrative, but it’s one you can easily lose track of amidst the glorious gameplay mayhem.

Relentless Momentum and Unholy Mayhem

Unlike games that allow you to take your time, explore, and soak in the atmosphere, Forgive Me Father 2 belongs to the other school of thought: the kind that doesn’t let you breathe for a moment. This is a game of relentless forward momentum. In each level you enter, your primary objective is to get from point A to point B, often collecting some special tokens along the way.

While there are some secrets to uncover and small environmental puzzles to solve, the main course on the menu is, without a doubt, shooting an unholy number of enemies.

Weapons and Enemies 

The bestiary is varied, starting with zombie-like grunts that just mindlessly run at you, before escalating to bigger brutes that require more than a few hits to take down. Then there are enemies that return fire, or cunning foes that hide behind shields, forcing you to aim for a small open window to land a killing blow. There are also grenade-lobbing enemies and even pesky foes that fly through the air. 

Forgive Me Father 2 review 2
Prepare to take on many varied enemies

Thankfully, you have an ever-expanding armoury to take them on. You start with a knife, then a pistol, then a shotgun, a grenade launcher, and an amazing stick-shooting ballista gun. Fairly simple at first glance, yes? But you can then upgrade these basic weapons with tokens found amongst the levels to transform them into something truly special and bizarre. The pistol turns into a fish-gun that horrifyingly fires out the spines of a pufferfish. The rifle can be upgraded so that eldritch tentacles emerge to wrap around your enemies’ arms. The sheer invention of these weapons, all perfectly based around the game’s Lovecraftian themes, is truly one of the game’s absolute highlights.

The Cycle of Carnage

The gameplay loop is incredibly fast and frantic. There is an argument to be made that the constant respawning of enemies and the non-stop fighting can get a bit samey after a while, but when the heavy metal music is playing and the adrenaline is pumping, this is simply good old-fashioned shooter fun. Strafing, circle-strafing, and constant movement are the absolute keys to success, as getting trapped in a corner is a death sentence. You’ll also be desperately picking up ammo, armour, and health, as you’ll find yourself running out of everything very quickly. 

Beyond the core shooting, there are other mechanics at play, such as a powerful “Book” special ability that can turn the tide of a battle, and a dynamo torch that needs constant winding up when you’re navigating pitch-black areas. This, combined with the classic puzzle element of finding colour-coded keys for their respective doors, adds just enough variety to the chaos. It really is a lot of fun.

Comic Book Carnage and Crushing Chords

Forgive Me Father 2’s visuals are, of course, similar to the first entry in the series, and that’s by no means a bad thing. It’s a hand-drawn, graphic novel style that works so well with this genre. In this sequel, everything seems a bit better, with improved models, more detailed environments, and some fantastic lighting effects. I particularly love the use of comic book panels; for instance, when a door is unlocked, you’ll see it open in a small panel in the top-right corner of the screen. It’s great stuff. 

And then we have the audio. The music is heavy metal and rock all the way through, perfectly accompanying the frantic pace of the gameplay. The voice-over is good, with a gruff, noir feel to it that fits perfectly with the vibe.

Forgive Me Father 2 review 3
Forgive Me Father 2 – a cracking sequel

A Shooter That Delivers on All Fronts

This sequel is so well-executed that it has made me re-evaluate my review of the first game; this iteration simply feels smoother to play and is altogether more exciting. Forgive Me Father 2 is an old-school shooter, but it brings enough new ideas to the table in terms of its wildly imaginative weapons and intriguing story. I loved the core gameplay loop this time around, but can still understand how its relentless nature might become wearying for some players after a while. 

I think the Forgive Me Father franchise will keep on coming, and I, for one, won’t stand in its way.


Ready to Embrace the Insanity? Forgive Me Father 2 Blasts onto Xbox and PS5! – https://www.thexboxhub.com/ready-to-embrace-the-insanity-forgive-me-father-2-blasts-onto-xbox-and-ps5/

Buy Forgive Me Father 2 from the Xbox Store – https://www.xbox.com/en-gb/games/store/forgive-me-father-2/9mx24tvw0pwq


SUMMARY

Pros:
  • Tight, exciting gameplay
  • Fantastic weapon variety
  • Great graphic-novel visuals
  • Rocking music
Cons:
  • Lacks variety at times
Info:
  • Massive thanks for the free copy of the game, Fulqrum Publishing
  • Formats - Xbox Series X|S (review), PS5
  • Not Available on Game Pass Day One
  • Not Xbox Play Anywhere Enabled
  • Release date | Price - 23 September 2025 | £TBC
Gareth Brierley
Gareth Brierleyhttp://www.garethbrierley.co.uk
I am an actor and a writer. I act quite a bit on stage, a little bit on tv and never on tuesdays. I have had some of my writing published and have written for TV and stage. I have been playing games since they begun and don't seem to be getting any better.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Retrospectives

2026's Most Anticipated

We give you our most anticipated new Xbox and Game Pass games set to launch in 2026. 

Xbox Goes VR

Join The Chat

Latest

This Month's Best New Games

Here’s a closer look at the most anticipated Xbox releases to mark on your calendar - we’ve narrowed it down to 10 of the very best Xbox and Game Pass releases for February 2026. 

Our Current Team

James Birks
2885 POSTS23 COMMENTS
Dave Ozzy
1624 POSTS2 COMMENTS
Richard Dobson
1391 POSTS19 COMMENTS
Paul Renshaw
1304 POSTS46 COMMENTS
Fin
1249 POSTS0 COMMENTS
Darren Edwards
513 POSTS2 COMMENTS
Ryan Taylor
175 POSTS0 COMMENTS
George WL Smith
16 POSTS0 COMMENTS
Matt Evans
15 POSTS0 COMMENTS
Gabriel Annis
7 POSTS4 COMMENTS
Adam Carr
6 POSTS0 COMMENTS
Matt Martindale
4 POSTS0 COMMENTS
Kyle Wendt
3 POSTS0 COMMENTS

Join the chat

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

<b>Pros:</b> <ul> <li>Tight, exciting gameplay</li> <li>Fantastic weapon variety</li> <li>Great graphic-novel visuals</li> <li>Rocking music</li> </ul> <b>Cons:</b> <ul> <li>Lacks variety at times</li> </ul> <b>Info:</b> <ul> <li>Massive thanks for the free copy of the game, Fulqrum Publishing</li> <li>Formats - Xbox Series X|S (review), PS5 <li>Not Available on Game Pass Day One <li>Not Xbox Play Anywhere Enabled</li> <li>Release date | Price - 23 September 2025 | £TBC</li> </ul>Forgive Me Father 2 Review
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x