A No-Thrills Sokoban That Walks Back The Goodwill From The First Game
I’m not sure that Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets makes a lick of sense, and it only makes me want to find out more. You play a goat who, as far as we can tell, works for the warmer side of the afterlife. But rather than torment the souls of pets, this goat is pushing them around Hell so that they can pass through portals and go to Heaven. Isn’t that a premise that just makes you want to ask questions?
It’s not the first time that the goat has cleared out the afterlife, either. Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets is the sequel to last year’s Goat Out of Hell, which shows that the goat has been doing it for quite some time.

Best Played With Meatloaf On In The Background
Strip away all the ghosts and lava backdrops, and Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets is very much the conventional box-pushing sokoban. In each level, you are given a grid layout, and within that layout is one or more animal spirits. You’d think that they are incorporeal, but they are very much not: you can shuffle these spirits around by walking into them. Push them from below and they move up, and so on.
Alongside the ghosts are one or more portals. These occultish squares are the goal for your animal spirits: you need to nudge them inside the portals so that the animal can pass over to – what we assumed to be – the other side (we still have so many questions). A spirit doesn’t need to go into a specific portal. The order is entirely up to you.
As with any sokoban, the challenge is to keep the pushable blocks ‘in play’ at all times, and never get them stuck. It’s easier to do that than you might imagine. Corners are the enemy: there is no physical method of retrieving a block/animal soul once it’s lodged into a corner. But you can easily make things harder for yourself by pushing a block against a wall, or nudging two blocks together. It limits what you can do with the block in question.
If At First You Don’t Succeed…
As with all sokoban from Afil Games, you won’t be stuck for long. Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets comes fully kitted out with an instantaneous Retry button, plus the ability to ‘Undo’ every move you’ve made in the puzzle. I’ve been meaning to test the limits of this feature: just how many moves can it actually remember? You certainly won’t be finding out unless you go out of your way to lose.

Comparing Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets to its predecessor does the sequel no favours. In the first game, you weren’t just pushing animal spirits about. You were also nudging blocks, and those blocks could be dumped into holes to make bridges. It turns out that Hell has a pothole problem. But there are no potholes or concrete blocks here at all.
It still utterly bemuses me why Afil Games does this. They will take one of their established games that presumably did well. Then they will release a sequel that strips out the thing that made the original unique. There’s no thought that ‘perhaps what we’re stripping out is what made the first game popular’. Nobody says ‘perhaps we should give it another name if it’s a different game from the original’. Instead, we get a tasteless interpretation of the original and look around bemused, wondering why someone would bother.
Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets could have done with an addition like concrete blocks and bridges. Aside from the odd Hell backdrop, it does nothing that hundreds of sokoban haven’t done before. It’s awash with over-familiarity. There are puzzle layouts in here that I feel like I have played before, and nothing surprised or truly confounded. It’s all so done.
Far From The Greatest-of-All-Time
If I were to dig out a compliment, it would be that the puzzle layouts are of a high order in Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets. They may give me deja vu, but they are more difficult than the average, and I found myself making hundreds of moves in the attempt to find a solution. Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets has the cunning ability to make you feel like you’re travelling in circles (of Hell), when you are actually making progress. You’re on the other side of a wall of blocks, and that’s what you needed to begin the chain reaction to victory.

But I can’t bring myself to recommend Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets. It’s not bad, but it’s achingly familiar. You could throw a rock on the Xbox Store and hit any number of sokobans that are like it. It’s painful because the first Goat Out of Hell did actually try something new. Its blocks + bridges motifs were a step in the right direction, but that step has been rewound and removed here. It’s inexplicable to me why you’d want to lose something that gave Goat Out of Hell: Lost Pets a chance to stand out.
All that I’m left with is questions. Why is a devil goat helping lost souls? Doesn’t the Devil have something to say about it? Alas, I’m going to have to store the questions away until Goat Out of Hell 3.
Important Links
Goat Out Of Hell: Lost Pets Takes A Gentler Trip Through The Underworld – https://www.thexboxhub.com/goat-out-of-hell-lost-pets-takes-a-gentler-trip-through-the-underworld/
Buy from the Xbox Store – https://www.xbox.com/en-GB/games/store/goat-out-of-hell-lost-pets-xbox-series/9PLZX2TVKDV5/0010

